I'm really glad PFT did this show because otherwise I either wouldn't have found out about it or wouldn't have given it a fair shake. Although I've never seen Pollak's standup, I have generally found him to be a funny guy (his Albert Brooks impression is AMAZING). However, Pollak the dramatic actor I've had more trouble with, especially his performance as a tough-guy bank robber in Usual Suspects, which I consider to be both the only blemish on an otherwise perfect movie and the second-worst case of miscasting in movie history (first being John Wayne playing Genghis Khan in The Conqueror).
The show is terrific, though. Pollak is a great host and a great interviewer, and as others have pointed out, it's great to see that he's done his homework. I've only listened to two or three episodes so far but I have a bunch of others waiting to go. The Eddie Izzard episode was very entertaining for a number of reasons. He claims to be very uncomfortable about receiving compliments, and Pollak was so effusive with his praise that I started wondering if Pollak was messing with him.
Side question: Izzard seems to be rather unpopular with comedy nerds, especially alternative comedy fans. Has this always been the case, or has there been a recent turn against him?