Yeah, yeesh. The funny thing is, that thread has exactly all the weird obsessive culty characteristics that FOTs are being accused of therein. I actually think this board is kinda nice, and I'm perfectly comfortable drifting in and out of it, though I do have kind of a man-crush on Tom.
Someone needs to come up with a name for this sort of phenomenon on the internets. It reminded me a LOT of this recent event in the theater blogosphere - basically a blogger went to see a preview of a play at Playwrights' Horizons in NY, hated it, left at intermission, and trashed it on his blog. There was this ridiculous blogs-linking-to-blogs-linking-to-blogs argument, as if this blogger had tried to kill somebody. I actually happen to be really good friends with the director and he had no idea any of this was going on. No one at the theater did. In fact, it hasn't really made a difference at all, the show is selling out. I pointed this out on one of the blogs, and mentioned maybe, just maybe, this was a tempest in a teapot, and bloggers (including me) are nowhere near as important as we tend to think we are. I didn't exactly get my head bitten off, but there was a lot of bloviation, even though I was pointing out the obvious.
Anyway, I don't if I'm making the connection adequately clear here, but there is a kind of crazymaking feeling one gets from reading these obsessive, black-hole arguments online.