Haha...no, Smiley's got a normal amount of toes.
The cat who was supposed to be "interviewed" in that episode, Mugsy, is indeed a "mitten cat," with freakish thumbs.
But once we got to Mugsy's apartment and the camera was on, she TOTALLY CHOKED. She couldn't hold it together. We came back to my place and re-shot it with Smiley, who is a PRO.