
After years of being perplexed by this band, I've recently turned the corner. Still haven't heard everything yet, but I'm making my way through the catalog.
London Calling is a good, but overrated album. Not their best work, IMO.
I don't think they ever topped their debut album, personally.
Of the three I've heard so far, this is how I'd rank them in terms of preference:
1. London Calling
2. Combat Rock
3. s/t (UK version, in case you're wondering)
The rootsy sprawl of London Calling really puts me in mind of Exile on Main Street, which is also the sound of a band mastering its own influences and really making them a part of the band's sound. Despite the wide range of sounds being pulled into the stew, it sounds tight and coherent and like the work of a single band. There are a couple of misfires (The Card Cheat is a swing and a miss at Born To Run-era Springsteen, and I don't know what the hell Koka Kola is), but it's pretty hard to complain when you look at what surrounds them.
The straight punk of the debut, on the other hand, sounds a bit toothless to me in comparison with some of my favorites from the era. Maybe it's because I heard the later albums first, but this sounds to me like a band struggling to find an identity. "White Riot" in particular just sounds like a semi-finalist entry from a Ramones cover competition. There are some great songs on here, don't get me wrong. It's possible I'll warm to it later.
In any case, I look forward to hearing the other 2. Is Cut The Crap even worth tracking down? I know its poor reputation, but I don't know if it's earned.