Saddest Turf/Flame out: Harry (like Harry Potter) from Rutherford, New Jersey (September 16, 2008 show)
Harry burned so hot from the beginning, it was nearly destined for him to flame out. I still laugh thinking about Harry describing the star of Uncle Stevie's film "Overdrive," as "Emilio Estevez...Sheen!" Then he goes on to describe his affinity for PBR, who he seems to believe is a real person. If that wasn't enough, he has very developed views on which diner in the Jersey area has the best chocolate cream pie.
Sadly, Harry called back a few times and was shut down almost immediately. I hope he wasn't deterred, but I haven't heard him call in awhile.
Also, I don't want to get into anything unseemly, but if there were a Cutest Voice category, Maya from Brooklyn would win this hands down. (Also September 16, 2008 show, right after Harry's call)