Speaking as Junior Best Show Shovel.com Liaison (not sure what Matthew Fluxblog's two cents are), 7.9* is pretty conservative. Thompson makes some great cases for the record, but the cases against -- mostly in the lyrics department -- I don't agree with at all. The directness is what makes a lot of it hit hard, if you ask me.
*even though it's a hair away from the equivalent of four stars -- I dunno, focusing on the number ratings without actually reading the article is moron stuff anyways.