I find Pixar movies pretty dull, overall. They seem like superior kids' movies - which is fine, except they're always treated as grown-up movies. I voted The Incredibles, just because I like superheroes.
I also find them visually dull. The amazing thing about animation is that you can do ANYTHING with it, and Pixar is mostly dedicated (like Disney) to recreating the real world as accurately as possible. I want animation to blow my mind!