I've been listening to a lot of shows circa 2006-2008 lately and Tom's genuine fascination with Spike peaks around the winter 05/06. After a year or two of non-sensical calls about Debby the Dominatrix and The Dungeon, Tom breaks through and discovers all the fundamentals of the Spike Universe: Doo-wop, daytime television, his anti-youth anti-women stances, his "I Don't Do"s (malls, "Satan Island"), his Mad Magazine style of satire ("Seance"), love of slasher superstars Chucky, Freddy, and Jason, and his support of the Democratic Party.
Unfortunately, Spike's calls rarely broke this pattern for the next 8 years, the exceptions being his fandom of soap/"porn" actor John Wesley Shipp ("was he Flesh Gordon? So's he's a porno actor?") and his ill-fated "Weirdos Exposed" "book", which for some reason only kept at his job.
Spike was good fodder on those slow Goshin summer nights.
February 21, 2006: Craig Cooper From Radio Hut Checks In, The 'Build A Movie Game' Is Birthed, Some Theme Song Songs, Another Revealing Call From Spike And More!
PS I also think this might be Dave from Knoxville's first call as "Ezekiel from Locust Ridge Tennessee" who asks about the metrosexuals in Wash DC. at about 40 mins in.