I'm relatively new to the forums (lurked from time to time, but never posted.) Part of the reason I finally joined is because I've gotten so tired of trying (unsuccessfully) to get friends, or frankly, anyone I know into the Best Show. It's one of my favorite things in the world, and yet I never get to share it with anyone.
My "in" was recommendations from other things I was a fan of, and the first few episodes I listened to were ones with comedians I liked guesting. And, admittedly, there was a curve to me really loving the show the way I do now, but I was hooked after just a couple episodes. I've tried playing specific segments that don't need a lot of context for people, sent them Best Show Gems...nothing.
So, have you ever successfully "won a soul" for the Best Show? What worked for you? Or is everyone I know just a giant bummer ?