I too have now caught up with tons of Nardwuar YouTube clips. Almost ruined my entire workday, I was glued for hours. But I'm not complaining, as now I've come around - I GET IT. I do stand by my first impression, but there's no denying his ability to get to his interview subjects. Really entertaining, especially his interviews with people from the hiphop community. You can tell how impressed these jaded guys are when someone comes along and actually has done his homework. Some of the shtick is a bit annoying though, and I can see how that can be off-putting if you don't know the context - there's so many sub-MTV shows out there with whacky hosts and shady intentions that you're bound to be on the defensive when a guy like Nardwuar comes along. Still, that doesn't excuse the absolute assholish behaviour on display in the interviews with Sonic Youth ('91) or Blur ('03!).
And it's almost spooky how much he sounds (not looks, as we know that's rule #1) like JW. I mean really, the pitch of his voice, not to mention the insane pop trivia and everything. Minus the Canadian accent of course.