NEW! Best Show Poster

[Paul DeLouisiana]

Am I the only FOT who listens to TBS with a window tab devoted to Google image search?

[Key Loser]

Am I the only FOT who listens to TBS with a window tab devoted to Google image search?

[dave from knoxville]

Yah, where's the Neil Numberman etsy page?

[Lothar_Brightblade]

I would guess that 28 is H-Man, and 29 is either Little Bill or Pudge.

Obviously, we can never know what H-Man really looks like.  (Can you imagine if he was real?  That would be SO WEIRD.)

I thing 29 is one of the bills as well, especially after looking back at their (Neil Numberman illustrated) trading card.

[neilnumberman]

Thought I'd give this a push in the right direction...

1. Tom Scharpling
2. Spike
3. Zach Galifinakis
4. John Hodgman
5. Patton Oswalt
6. Paul F. Tompkins
7. The drummer from the Superchunks
8. AP Mike
9. Teddy Rockstar aka Ted Leo
10. Julie Klausner?
10.5. That guy who called in to the show ... the one who’s an aging Brooklyn hipster who owns a shop that sells really stupid stuff.
11. Ms. Jillian Barberie
12. Wallace Wackiman
13. Dogmo
14. The Great State of New Jersey
15. The planet Earth, in a terlet.
16. Timmy Von Trimble
17. A Monkey in a Diaper (last seen in Huntsville Alabama).
18. Ben Gibbard
18.5.  Terese
19. Larry D. Pervison
20. Aimee Mann
21. Bryce
22. Marky Ramone?
23. Rodrigo the Drum Pin Salesman?
24. Micky Dolenz
25. Gene Simmons
26. Dave from Knoxville
27. The Gorch
28.
29.
30.
31. Andy Daly
32. Darren Ploppleton? Hippy Johnny?
33. Claude Monroe of the Newbridge Knights
34. Luther Campbell?
35. Julie From Cincinnati?
36. HORSE
37. Judge Montgomery Davies
38. Eric Wareheim
39. Kevin “GG” Allin
40. Tim Heidecker
41. Chris Elliot
42. Zachary L. Brimstead
43 and 44 .. More of the Murder Junkies? … I don’t know, I’m getting pretty lost here. Help me out , people. Maybe 44 is Hammerhead?
45. Paul Scheer
46. Hot Rockin' Ronny
47. Laura from Magic City?
48. Bishop Juan Pablo Fontanna
49. Esteemed filmmaker Kevin Smith
50. Mr. Sherbet?
51. Buzz from "Tramp Stamp"
52. Todd Barry
53. Lisa Jane Persky
54. you got JAMESED!!
55. Evan Funk Davies?
56. Damian from Effed Up
57. Andy from Lake Newbridge
58. Frederics!!
59. Michael from the Cynics? (I  have no idea what Michael from the Cynics looks like, but I just got a feeling about this one).
60. Philly Boy Roy!
61. Jen Kirkman!
62. Karl the Repairman
63.
64. MC Steinberg?
65. Candace from Brooklyn, the human jukebox/karaoke machine

[oilcantim]

Way to play it coy, Neil.  (Brilliant job, by the way!)

[sockhead]

I think #43 is Reggie Monroe. The Survivor buff and the presence of fluids give me that impression.

#59 looks dressed like a film director, so Trent L. Strauss?

[buffcoat]

These were said before but let's make them official:

10.5 Barry Dworkin
16 Officer Tom Bobblehead Doll
46 Glenn Danzig

I'm betting sockhead is right about:

59 Trent L. Strauss

[Mr. Spacely]

The big mystery for me is who the guy in the baseball hat is.  We know he's not Claude Monroe. Is it Frank Monroe, the former pro ballplayer? Sorry, I'm obsessed with the Monroes when I'm not busy studying Darren.

[sockhead]

These were said before but let's make them official:

I'm betting sockhead is right about:

59 Trent L. Strauss

I'm more sure about Reggie than I am about Strauss (There's 2 people wearing berets in the top row - and one fish!) so if you could enter my guess for verification, I'd be thrilled.

[fonpr]

[ if you could enter my guess for verification, I'd be thrilled.

Buff?

[sockhead]

[ if you could enter my guess for verification, I'd be thrilled.

Buff?

The Survivor nickname for the headbands/handkerchiefs they wear on the show. (I'll admit it, I watch Survivor)

[fonpr]

[ (I'll admit it, I watch Survivor)

Eye of the Tiger - Survivor [Rock Band 2 Expert Vocals]{100% 5 Gold Stars}

[buffcoat]

[ if you could enter my guess for verification, I'd be thrilled.

Buff?

I've entered it.  I'll let you both know when I hear back.

[Mr. Spacely]

[ if you could enter my guess for verification, I'd be thrilled.

Buff?

I've entered it.  I'll let you both know when I hear back.

Whoa, whoa.  Slow down, son.

I made the Reggie call back on page 4!

"43 is Reggie Monroe.  I think that red thing on his head is not a visor, but a Survivor "buff."