It's funny, speaking of Kevin...
A week or so after I downloaded that first Rock, Rot and Rule mp3 from Soulseek, I had started combing through the actual RealAudio archives of the show. I had only known about the "Wurster" side of the Best Show facade, but did not know about Andy Earles.
The first time I heard one of his calls (it was the "Samson" call, when he mistakenly called the show, thinking it was a telephone dating service), I was so stupefied, that while I was listening to this bizarre call, I typed search terms into Google, trying to verify if the names and places that were being mentioned did indeed exist. I actually needed to do that, because at that point, the persona that Earles was playiing was just plausible enough for me to believe that such a man could actually exist.
Once I found that Google had nada on "Cockatoo Carl's" and "Casa del Agua Caliente Apartments", I knew that I finally, officially "got" The Best Show on WFMU.