I feel like the Best Show and I have been ships in the night for years and I'm kind of embarrassed that it took me so long to notice, but ultimately I came to it via my beloved Superchunk. I honestly can't remember the order of events, but someone told me a long time ago that the drummer from Superchunk also did comedy in some context and I thought that was the greatest thing I'd ever heard. I think I was already vaguely aware of the Rock, Rot & Rule premise when I saw Jon do a micro-interview as RTC at SXSW. Eventually I found out that Jon's comedy was somehow related to "that half-hour Smirnoff Ice thing with Jon Benjamin" that my then-boyfriend had played for me a year prior (I remember Googling it later, coming up with the Best Show archive page and being very, very confused). But the tipping point was when a friend of mine made me listen to two straight hours of Scharpling & Wurster calls on a bus ride to Philly, namely Gas Station Dogs, the first Mother 13, the first Philly Boy Roy, and at my request, the Smirnoff Ice call (and maybe something else that I'm forgetting). I immediately started listening on Tuesdays and devouring podcasts and archives and have been a hopeless wreck ever since.
On the upside, playing catch-up is really, really fun.