I agree, Tom Waits gets a lot of passes from critics. I think he goes through some unlistenable phases.
Fishing With John was great because it didn't conceal how pissed he got at John Lurie for dragging him out to the middle of nowhere.
He fetishized old-timey music for kids, who are impressed with being old, shitty, and homeless. I know a guy who worked at a liquor store for most of his youth because it was what Tom Waits would do. Bad influence on the aimless, that one.
C