The Killer's album? I don't know. They're both poppy as all hell, which is great, but Arcade Fire grabs me in a way the Killers never will--- I feel like it's more...organic?? (don't hate me for using that word). The Killers have some fun radio singles, but I never really want to play their albums over and over like I do with Arcade Fire.
I'm really not crazy about the first song on Neon Bible...which kind of sucks, because for me a good first song is crucial. But the rest of the album is steller...especially the song "Intervention".
They've got kind of a Bruce Springsteen thing going on this album as well, which is just great. I saw them at Randall's island last month...and they were one of the best live bands I've ever seen...dare I say the best?