I don't really come around these parts (as I'm sure you'll notice that I've made about 20 posts in 3 years), but I decided to chime in on this thread.
In March of 2006, I went over a friend's house. He was listening to the Best Show on the actual radio (I grew up in the 90.1 area), specifically the episode where he was talking about Abercrombie and Fitch CEO Mike Jeffries. I walked in, just as the deconstruction of the article started, and knew I was in love with the show when he said "You're lookin totally A&F today dude!" and was talking about people wearing flip-flops and the sound they make. I made my friend not only listen to more of the show, but when we went out to get a slice of pizza, I made him put it on in the car. And that's about when Wurster called as Trent L. Strauss. We got to the pizza place and sat in the car for 20 minutes laughing the entire time until he hung up. I honestly did not know if it was real or not, but it was damn funny. I think once he started threatening Tom, I figured it wasn't real, but nonetheless they had me fooled for a good 45 minutes. So I started going through the archives. I've only gone about a year back from that point in total (the oldest one I heard was Tom's "return" to the air from the "move" to Sirius) but pretty much everything I've ever heard from that point onward is incredible.
I've called a few times. Nothing memorable (except for MAYBE the episode where Tom had people putting together their slap lists - I was the guy that wanted to slap Fox for canceling Arrested Development - Tom rejected my list and made me slap myself). Unfortunately, I don't really have time to listen live anymore, nor do I have time to contribute (besides marathon time, of course). But the Best Show, for me personally, is something I don't need to be active in to enjoy. Hearing Tom's ridiculous reactions to everything give me some of the my biggest laughs.
And here are some of my absolute favorite Best show moments:
- My absolute favorite calls are Trent L. Strauss, Philly Boy Roy (Crawlspaces and Cheesesteaks), Zachery Brimstead (Supernova, Laser Beans, The Fudge Tub, and Racism), The guy who was on To Catch a Predator, Jimmy Crespo, Darren from Work (Aquasitions with Patton Oswalt), Gene Simmions (Newbridge Mayubinatorial Race, Poncake), Pretty much every Marky Ramone call, and every Bryce call ever. Seriously I want a return of Bryce.
- On the 1/24/2006 show, someone called in trying to get Tom to answer a riddle about 3 mice in a mousehole. Tom guesses the riddle immediately, and the other guy demands that he doesn't. Tom gets mad, and the whole thing ends with one of the best rope-a-dope GOMPs ever.
- Not sure on the exact show, but someone calls up asking Tom if he'll go to a Grouse hunt, where the DJ will be spinning House and Techno. The guy curses on the air, and Tom dumps him, and starts going off on the guy, and starts doing an impression of a house record. I die laughing every time he says the word "Touque".
- Tom making fun of James. There's a whole bit about someone giving him a tube of Wig Glue that cracks me up every time.
- And of course, the obligatory Cowboy Star, Gathering of the Juggalos, Tom Jameses James, Hest Rope-A-Dope, The World is in the Turlet, etc.