I never read this Podmass review in my life, but checked it out when Tom mentioned it on Twitter today:
"The Best Show On WFMU
It’s week one of the Regular Caller Ban on The Best Show, though the rule isn’t strictly enforced, because Julie from Cincinnati is actually in the studio to tell a good story about what landed her in prison. Calls from non-regulars include a person who was once mistaken for Wayne Knight and another whose father was beaten up at a hardcore festival. Tom Scharpling goes on several extended riffs on the banes of his existence (buffet hogs, his high-school bullies, and lists of the best comedian tweeters), but the highlight of the episode is a call from Philly Boy Roy, who discusses all the surprise indie guests at this year’s Gathering Of The Juggalos. That said, without a guest, this week’s episode misses some of the usual magic."
Has this guy/gal even listened to some episodes before 2011?
Seems to me he/she isn't fit (too ignorant of the canon) to give an opinion on the astounding self-referential loop the whole show was set up for.