I love the idea of an archive podcast, or a Best Show Vault podcast. Generally I try to talk up the show wherever I can, but it is an acquired taste, which (cf. Sarah) is part of what makes it so awesome.
Alternately, maybe we could do an "Ultimate Best Show," where we trash the last decade's worth of continuity and start at zero - Ultimate Tom, Ultimate Clontle, Ultimate Philly Boy Roy. Where's Wes?